Michigan Declares ‘Financial Martial Law’: Democracy Endangered?

Michigan has just joined Ohio and Wisconsin in passing a law that seeks to limit the power of unions. This one arguably goes further than the now-infamous limitation on collective bargaining rights in Wisconsin: it bestows state-appointed financial managers the right to terminate union contracts in cases where cities and school districts have unbalanced budgets. Or as the bill’s supporters say, cases where “financial martial law” is necessary. After the bill was proposed, protests erupted around Michigan. After it was passed, they intensified — so far, 11 have been arrested at Michigan’s capital building in Lansing.

The idea behind the bill is that it allows these financial managers to swiftly and decisively balance budgets in cities and school districts on the verge of financial collapse. But it also appears to circumvent the democratic process by giving authority to arbiters hired by the state to overturn contracts that have been negotiated in good faith for years. In that sense, it seems a uniquely authoritarian law.

Here’s a closer look at some of the logic from the supporters of the bill, via Politico:

Supporters say the bill gives the state a way to step into distressed municipalities and schools before they collapse. It also gives emergency financial managers broad authority to end employee union contracts, and to nullify elected boards and councils. The bill’s sponsor, Republican Rep. Al Pscholka, said Tuesday that it would give the state the power it needs to dig important institutions out of financial holes. “For years we have allowed cities and schools to be on the verge of bankruptcy without any intervention,” he told Reuters.

But the teachers, firefighters, autoworkers, health service workers, and the other labor groups that comprise the backbone of Michigan’s workforce don’t see it that way. Dianne Feeley, a retired auto worker who joined the protests in Lansing, wrote the following in an op-ed on Truthout:

On March 8 a thousand Michiganders—including firefighters, teachers, office workers, health care workers, auto workers and steelworkers—rallied at the state Capitol in Lansing, filling all three floors of the rotunda and demanding “kill the bill.” We were opposing legislation that would give astounding unchecked power to emergency managers appointed by the governor when he or she decides local municipalities or school districts are in financial trouble. These powers include firing elected officials, tearing up union contracts, outsourcing, slashing services, and selling off public assets without competitive bidding.

Whether or not this measure furthers the aim of balancing budgets, to me, there’s no getting around the fact that it would do so in a pretty bluntly anti-democratic manner. It eliminates a whole group of people’s rights to negotiate for their standard of living, and shifts the decision-making power on such matters over to the state — and it leaves the middle class with no immediate recourse. The state’s agents can now go through cities on a case-by-case budget, and tear up union contracts if it they deem them too cumbersome. This sets a dangerous, undemocratic precedent in yielding power to the state and siphoning it from locally elected bodies, and the working class in general. Why should one particular team of financial consultants get to determine the fate of entire groups of people’s standard of living?

Follow the Utopianist on Twitter and Facebook.

Image: la58

About Brian Merchant

Brian Merchant is a founding editor of the Utopianist.. When he's not helming the Utopianist, he is TreeHugger's politics writer, contributes the Getting Samy Out of Burma column to GOOD.is, and freelances for the likes of Salon and Paste. He lives in Brooklyn, New York.

45 thoughts on “Michigan Declares ‘Financial Martial Law’: Democracy Endangered?

  1. 543857 781487Your weblog is among the far better blogs Ive came across in months. Thank you for your posts and all of the finest together with your function and weblog. Searching forward to reading new entries! 617514

  2. 969496 610883Having read this I thought it was quite informative. I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this post together. I once once again uncover myself spending strategy to considerably time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was nonetheless worth it! 719698

  3. 564431 109997When do you feel this Real Estate market will go back in a positive direction? Or is it nonetheless too early to tell? We are seeing a great deal of housing foreclosures in Altamonte Springs Florida. What about you? Would really like to get your feedback on this. 683056

  4. 493825 137345Hello there. I required to inquire some thingis this a wordpress web site as we are thinking about transferring across to WP. Moreover did you make this theme all by yourself? Cheers. 518819

  5. The theory from the topic is actually discussed in detail in natural’law ebooks, which provide specifics of important
    cases related to the following subject while real’life
    examples of the theories, for example Lochner vs Big apple,
    Near versus Minnesota, the particular Pentagon Papers case plus Bob Smith
    University versus United States And so, for anyone who is having bad credit issues such as defaults, financial obligation, CCJs, IVA, foreclosure, late installments, skipping with
    installments and even bankruptcy may also apply for these funds without
    the need of going through almost any credit checks

  6. 962088 179124Wow, superb weblog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging appear straightforward. The overall appear of your web site is magnificent, as properly as the content material! xrumer 335924

  7. 565309 539622Hello! I just now would like to supply a massive thumbs up for any great details you can have here within this post. We are coming back to your weblog post for further soon. 556093

  8. 255003 944175Usually the New york Weight Loss diet is certainly less expensive and flexible staying on your diet scheme intended for measures however fast then duty keep a nutritious daily life. weight loss 409405

  9. 122989 377491My wife style of bogus body art were being quite unsafe. Mother worked with gun very first, right after which they your lover snuck free of charge upon an tattoo ink ink. I was positive the fact just about every need to not be epidermal, due towards the tattoo ink could be attracted from the entire body. make an own temporary tattoo 175390

  10. 174636 953380Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice whilst you amend your web website, how can i subscribe for a blog web site? The account aided me a appropriate deal. I had been just a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear concept 778565

  11. 130871 299696Largest lover messages were created to share it together with your and gives honour with the bride and groom. Really sound systems facing unnecessary throngs of folks need to take into account each of our valuable concept of all presenting, which is ones trailer. finest man toasts 68697

  12. 84827 839081Hiya! Wonderful weblog! I happen to be a everyday visitor to your web site (somewhat a lot more like addict ) of this site. Just wanted to say I appreciate your blogs and am seeking forward for a lot more to come! 533105

  13. 228855 627309Oh my goodness! an exceptional post dude. Thanks a good deal Even so Im experiencing dilemma with ur rss . Do not know why Struggle to register for it. Can there be any person obtaining identical rss concern? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx 569896

  14. 180804 338440Soon after study some with the weblog posts on your personal internet site now, we genuinely like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark internet internet site list and are checking back soon. Pls consider my web-site likewise and make me aware in case you agree. 31165

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *