Is it Worth Endangering Species to Scale Up Clean Power?

That question is more and more becoming a central one in the quest to bring renewable energy to scale. Renewable energy projects like solar power plants require lots of land — land that’s often inhabited by wildlife. But if we hope to deploy solar on a large-scale, might it be worth steam-rolling some desert tortoises?

That’s the question Forbes examines in a recent article, which tells the tale of a struggle between biologists who want to preserve an endangered desert tortoise and renewable energy advocates who hope to build the biggest solar project in the nation in the Mohave Desert. From the report:

Last October BrightSource Energy began construction on the first large-scale solar thermal power plant to be built in the U.S. in two decades. After an arduous three-year environmental review, a $1.6 billion federal loan guarantee and more than a half-billion dollars in investment from the likes of Google, Morgan Stanley and NRG Energy, Interior Secretary Ken Salazar and then California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger appeared at a sunny groundbreaking ceremony in Nipton, Calif., in the Mojave Desert. The 370-megawatt Ivanpah Solar Electric Generating System, they proclaimed, heralded a clean, green energy future.

But as the dignitaries speechified, biologists were discovering the creosote-bush-studded landscape was crawling with some uninvited guests: desert tortoises. Years of surveys had estimated that, at most, 32 of the iconic, imperiled animals called the 5.6-square-mile site home. But as giant road graders moved in, biologists had already found nearly that many tortoises just in the project’s first, 914-acre phase.

Federal biologists now say that there are hundreds of tortoises crawling around the site, and scientists “with the U.S. Bureau of Land Management, which leases the land to BrightSource, concluded that the project would “harass” 2,325 mostly juvenile tortoises living within a 2-kilometer radius outside the site in the Ivanpah Valley, where another company, First Solar, intends to construct two huge generating stations.”

Traditional conservationists are peeved, and are calling to halt the project, imperiling an already volatile investment in one of the nation’s pioneering clean energy projects. So, we return to the central dilemma — is it worth potentially sacrificing a population of endangered species to install clean power? And if we do this on a large scale, is it worth endangered potentially dozens more? The debate has pitted an older generation of environmentalists, those who identify mostly with conservationism, against a newer one — the one that’s enthused about clean energy and phasing out coal.

I find myself in squarely with the young ‘uns. Sorry, but we’ll lose far more than desert tortoises if we continue to draw our power from carbon polluting sources like coal plants — it’s time to start showing the nation, and the world, that clean energy is viable for deployment asap. We should aim the best conservation measures we’ve got at preserving endangered species of course, but if climate change kicks into high gear, it will devastate biodiversity around the globe, not just in California deserts.

Follow the Utopianist on Twitter and Facebook.

Photo credit: USFWS Pacific Southwest Region via Flickr/CC BY

About Brian Merchant

Brian Merchant is a founding editor of the Utopianist.. When he's not helming the Utopianist, he is TreeHugger's politics writer, contributes the Getting Samy Out of Burma column to GOOD.is, and freelances for the likes of Salon and Paste. He lives in Brooklyn, New York.

47 thoughts on “Is it Worth Endangering Species to Scale Up Clean Power?

  1. 938937 771675If your real friends know you as your nickname, use that nickname as your first name online. When you first friend someone, focus on making a personal comment that weaves connection. 701417

  2. If you are you can’t cope with the process by yourself, because so many
    lawful authorities are certainly not convinced all these arbiters are the best
    answer, hire a lawyer As a result, many people which go
    to BHPH stores are those using a bad credit ranking or have portrayed personal bankruptcy in past times

  3. 586523 399734Thank you a lot for sharing this with all people you actually recognize what youre speaking about! Bookmarked. Please additionally talk over with my web site =). We could have a hyperlink alternate arrangement among us! 401779

  4. 946564 55931This really is the suitable weblog for anybody who needs to seek out out about this subject. You notice so significantly its virtually laborious to argue with you (not that I actually would wantHaHa). You undoubtedly put a brand new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Excellent stuff, just excellent! 821608

  5. 713373 563651Aw, i thought this was an really very good post. In notion I would like to invest writing in this way moreover – taking time and actual effort to manufacture a quite very good article but exactly what do I say I procrastinate alot and no indicates apparently go completed. 163556

  6. 6673 307276I enjoyed reading this a lot I actually hope to read a lot more of your posts within the future, so Ive bookmarked your weblog. But I couldnt just bookmark it, oh no.. When I see quality websites like this 1, I like to share it with other people So Ive produced a backlink to your web site (from 142048

  7. 908876 913228I discovered your weblog internet site on google and check some of your early posts. Continue to maintain up the quite very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading far more from you later on! 274615

  8. 9220 562024Hello, Neat post. Theres an concern together along with your internet site in internet explorer, may possibly check this? IE nonetheless could be the marketplace leader and a huge component to folks will omit your wonderful writing because of this dilemma. 22605

  9. 250882 945176One can undertake all sorts of advised excursions with assorted limousine functions. Various offer fantastic courses and numerous can take clients for just about any ride your bike over the investment banking region, or even for a vacation to new york. ??????? 498896

  10. 243163 497413Hey there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to take a appear. Im undoubtedly enjoying the details. Im bookmarking and will likely be tweeting this to my followers! Superb weblog and outstanding style and style. 317489

  11. 368968 519268This douche bag loves his illegal bretheren because hes a itiaen with the world and we really should be ashamed of ourselves I got news for you Asswipe get your asswiping ass back towards the craphole exactly where you came from with all of your illegal beaners 656701

  12. 951249 310858Nicely picked details, a lot of thanks towards the author. It is incomprehensive in my experience at present, even so in common, the convenience and importance is mind-boggling. Regards and all of the very best .. 395825

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *